Justia U.S. 4th Circuit Court of Appeals Opinion Summaries
Articles Posted in Constitutional Law
In re: Application
The case centers on a government investigation into a leak of highly classified information regarding a military operation. After a news article revealed details previously unreported, authorities suspected that journalists associated with the news outlet might have communicated with confidential sources via LinkedIn. The government obtained two orders under the Stored Communications Act: one requiring LinkedIn to disclose metadata records for the journalists over an eighteen-month period, and another barring LinkedIn from informing anyone, including the journalists and their employer, about the existence of the orders for one year. LinkedIn challenged both orders, arguing that they were substantially overbroad and threatened First Amendment protections by sweeping in unrelated confidential sources.A magistrate judge for the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia found LinkedIn had standing but sided with the government on the merits, holding that LinkedIn could only challenge the orders based on logistical or practical burdens, not on overbreadth or constitutional grounds. The district court adopted this recommendation, rejecting LinkedIn’s arguments regarding overbreadth and First Amendment protections, and upholding both the Disclosure and Secrecy Orders. LinkedIn’s motion for access to ex parte materials and for reconsideration following new information about the government’s disclosure to the news outlet was also denied.Upon appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit found LinkedIn had standing to challenge both orders. The court held that the Disclosure Order was substantially overbroad, violating statutory and constitutional norms, and required the district court to narrow its scope. The court also held that the Secrecy Order was overly broad as a prior restraint and must be modified to allow LinkedIn to disclose the existence of the orders to a single vetted attorney for the news outlet. However, the court affirmed the district court’s denial of LinkedIn’s request for access to ex parte materials, citing national security concerns. The case was affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded. View "In re: Application" on Justia Law
Jackson v. Thomson Reuters America Corp.
A retired law enforcement officer in West Virginia initiated five separate lawsuits against several data broker companies, alleging they published his home address and unpublished telephone number online without his consent. He claimed these disclosures, made via “people search” services, also affected thousands of other similarly situated officials protected under West Virginia’s Daniel’s Law. The statute prohibits the dissemination of home addresses or unpublished phone numbers of certain judicial and law enforcement officials if a reasonable person would believe such disclosure would expose them to harassment or harm.The United States District Court for the Northern District of West Virginia reviewed consolidated motions to dismiss by the defendants. The district court found that the challenged provision of Daniel’s Law was a content-based restriction on speech, necessitating strict scrutiny under the First and Fourteenth Amendments. The court recognized the compelling state interest in protecting officials’ safety but concluded the statute was not narrowly tailored, as it imposed liability without requiring notice or knowledge of the protected status of individuals whose information was disclosed. The district court thus dismissed the actions, determining the law was facially unconstitutional.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit affirmed the district court’s judgment. The appellate court held that the statute regulated speech protected by the First Amendment, was content-based, and therefore subject to strict scrutiny. The court agreed that the law was not the least restrictive means to serve the state’s compelling interest because it lacked a notice requirement and imposed automatic liability. As a result, the Fourth Circuit held that the provision of West Virginia’s Daniel’s Law at issue violated the First and Fourteenth Amendments and affirmed the dismissal of the lawsuits. View "Jackson v. Thomson Reuters America Corp." on Justia Law
Doe v. Catholic Relief Services
An IT analyst who is openly gay was hired by a large, Catholic-affiliated nonprofit based in Maryland. At the time of hiring, he was told his husband would be covered under the organization’s dependent health benefits. However, several months after his employment began, the organization informed him that providing benefits to his same-sex spouse was contrary to its religious beliefs and terminated those benefits. The employee declined alternative compensation and ultimately resigned from the organization after several years.The employee sued in the United States District Court for the District of Maryland, bringing claims under federal and state employment discrimination laws, including Title VII, the Equal Pay Act, and the Maryland Fair Employment Practices Act (MFEPA). The district court granted summary judgment for the employee on the Title VII and Equal Pay Act claims and, after certifying questions to the Maryland Supreme Court regarding the scope of the MFEPA’s religious exemption, held a bench trial and entered judgment for the employee on the remaining MFEPA claim. The parties stipulated to damages, but the employer reserved the right to appeal on liability.The United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit reviewed the employer’s statutory and constitutional defenses. The court held that Title VII’s religious employer exemption does not shield religious organizations from liability for discrimination based on sex, even if the employment decision is rooted in religious belief. Similarly, under MFEPA, the court found the exemption applies only to employees whose duties directly further the core mission of the organization; the employee’s roles did not meet this test. The court also held that the Religious Freedom Restoration Act does not apply to suits between private parties. Constitutional arguments based on the First Amendment’s Religion Clauses and church autonomy doctrine were rejected as grounds for immunity. The Fourth Circuit affirmed the district court’s judgment on Title VII and MFEPA claims and dismissed the Equal Pay Act appeal as moot. View "Doe v. Catholic Relief Services" on Justia Law
Mason v. Talley
The plaintiff, a convicted inmate at Riverside Regional Jail, was placed in restrictive housing after being found with contraband, and later spent five months in the Restrictive Housing Unit (RHU) due to repeated infractions and misconduct. During this period, he experienced varying levels of confinement and privileges, including periods of isolation, limited access to recreation, and additional restrictions following disciplinary incidents. He was also shackled to a telephone on two occasions for several hours, during which he alleged suffering humiliation and physical discomfort.The United States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia granted summary judgment to the jail officials, both before and after limited discovery. The court dismissed all but two defendants and ordered production of any surveillance video related to the incidents. After reviewing the available evidence, including video footage, the district court rejected the plaintiff’s claims regarding conditions of confinement and due process violations.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit affirmed the district court’s judgment. The panel held that the district court did not abuse its discretion in granting summary judgment before discovery, as the plaintiff failed to show that additional evidence would have affected the outcome. Reviewing de novo, the Fourth Circuit concluded that the plaintiff’s placement in restrictive housing did not implicate a protected liberty interest under the Fourteenth Amendment because the conditions, duration, and review process did not constitute atypical and significant hardship. The court also found that the conditions of confinement—including the telephone shackling incidents—did not rise to the level of “extreme deprivation” required for an Eighth Amendment violation, and even if they had, the officials would be entitled to qualified immunity because no clearly established right was violated. The judgment of the district court was affirmed. View "Mason v. Talley" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Civil Rights, Constitutional Law
Lopez Garcia v. Guadian
Two individuals who had lived in the United States for many years after entering without inspection were detained by Immigration and Customs Enforcement in October 2025. Both were apprehended while living and working in the Washington, D.C. area, and had established significant ties to the community. Removal proceedings were initiated against them on the basis that they had entered the country without authorization. Following their detention, neither was given an opportunity for a bond hearing, a process that, prior to July 2025, would have typically been available to noncitizens in their circumstances unless they posed certain risks or had committed specific crimes—none of which applied to these individuals.After the Department of Justice adopted a new interpretation of the relevant immigration statute in July 2025, mandating detention for all noncitizens who entered without inspection under 8 U.S.C. § 1225(b)(2)(A), the individuals filed habeas petitions in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia. They argued that they were entitled to bond hearings under 8 U.S.C. § 1226(a) and that their continued detention violated due process. The district court agreed, granting habeas relief and ordering bond hearings under § 1226(a). During these hearings, immigration judges found neither individual posed a danger or flight risk, and both were released on bond. The government appealed, and the cases were consolidated.The United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit reviewed the district court’s grant of habeas relief de novo. The Fourth Circuit held that § 1226, not § 1225, governs the detention of noncitizens who have been present in the United States for years, regardless of their manner of entry. The court concluded that the statutory text, structure, history, and longstanding interpretation all supported this reading, and that detaining such individuals without bond hearings raised significant constitutional concerns. The court affirmed the district court’s grant of habeas relief, requiring bond hearings for the petitioners. View "Lopez Garcia v. Guadian" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Constitutional Law, Immigration Law
Edwards v. Witherspoon
While incarcerated at a North Carolina women’s correctional facility, the plaintiff learned she was pregnant and, due to her history of opioid use disorder, was prescribed medication for opioid withdrawal (MOUD) under a prison policy that restricted such treatment to pregnant inmates. When she went into labor, she was transported to the hospital and was shackled at various stages during labor, delivery, and her return to prison. After giving birth, the facility denied her further MOUD because she was no longer pregnant, instead providing a short course of alternative pain medication. She experienced significant withdrawal symptoms as a result. The plaintiff brought claims against various prison officials, alleging violations of the Eighth Amendment for the shackling and for denial of MOUD, as well as disability discrimination under the Americans with Disabilities Act and the Rehabilitation Act.The United States District Court for the Eastern District of North Carolina granted summary judgment to all defendants, finding no constitutional violations and that qualified immunity protected the officials. It also concluded that the plaintiff was not discriminated against under federal disability law because the MOUD program was limited to pregnant inmates.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit affirmed in part, vacated in part, and remanded. The Fourth Circuit held that, as to certain officials, there was a genuine dispute of fact regarding whether shackling the plaintiff during labor and postpartum, without evidence of a security or flight risk, violated the Eighth Amendment. The court also held that the denial of MOUD following pregnancy, pursuant to a categorical policy, could constitute deliberate indifference to serious medical needs under the Eighth Amendment, and that summary judgment was inappropriate for the medical officials involved. The court further vacated the lower court’s disposition of the plaintiff’s ADA and Rehabilitation Act claims, remanding for further proceedings. Summary judgment for other defendants was affirmed. View "Edwards v. Witherspoon" on Justia Law
US v. Smith
After police responded to a theft report at a convenience store in Chesterfield County, Virginia, Markel Trevon Smith and another individual were detained. A search of their vehicle revealed four firearms, including a Glock pistol equipped with a device converting it into a machinegun. This Glock bore three serial numbers: two had been scratched, leaving only partial digits visible, while one serial number remained fully legible. The firearm was traced using the unaltered serial number.Smith was indicted in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia for possession of a machinegun in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 922(o). He moved to dismiss, arguing that § 922(o) violated the Second Amendment, but the district court denied the motion. Smith then pled guilty. At sentencing, the court adopted the Presentence Report’s recommendation to apply a four-level enhancement under U.S. Sentencing Guidelines § 2K2.1(b)(4)(B)(i), which increases the offense level if any firearm has a serial number modified so that the original information is illegible or unrecognizable to the unaided eye. The district court reasoned that altering any serial number on the firearm warranted the enhancement, and sentenced Smith to 57 months’ imprisonment.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit affirmed Smith’s conviction, holding that § 922(o) does not violate the Second Amendment, either facially or as applied to Smith, because machineguns are not in common use for lawful purposes. However, the Fourth Circuit found that the district court erred in applying the serial number enhancement. The court held that the enhancement only applies where modifications render the firearm as a whole untraceable, which was not the case since one serial number remained fully legible. The appellate court therefore reversed the application of the enhancement, vacated Smith’s sentence, and remanded for resentencing without the enhancement. View "US v. Smith" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Constitutional Law, Criminal Law
Hayat v. Diaz
Police in Montgomery County, Maryland, responded to a high-priority call reporting that a Black male had placed three children into the trunk of a black Tesla, possibly indicating a kidnapping. Officers quickly traced the vehicle and address to Fareed Hayat. Upon arriving at his home, they found Hayat and his wife on the porch and initiated questioning. Hayat acted evasively, did not answer whether he had been at the location in question, cut off his wife’s conversation with officers, and attempted to retreat into his house, insisting the police could not enter. The officers prevented him from closing the door, entered the front hall, handcuffed Hayat, and checked on the children’s welfare. After confirming no kidnapping had occurred, the officers released Hayat.Hayat subsequently filed a lawsuit in the United States District Court for the District of Maryland against the officers, the Chief of Police, and Montgomery County. He alleged violations of his Fourth and Fourteenth Amendment rights, as well as various federal and state law claims. The district court dismissed most claims and granted summary judgment to the defendants on the remaining claims, finding that the officers had a reasonable suspicion justifying a Terry stop prior to Hayat’s retreat into his home. The court also held that the officers were justified in entering the home to complete the stop and to confirm the children’s welfare, given the exigency created by Hayat’s conduct.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit affirmed the district court’s judgment. The Fourth Circuit held that the officers had reasonable articulable suspicion to justify a Terry stop based on corroborated eyewitness accounts and Hayat’s suspicious behavior. The court further held that entry into the home was justified to complete the Terry stop and to ensure the safety of the children, under both the exigent circumstances and “hot pursuit” exceptions to the warrant requirement. The court concluded that Hayat’s Fourth Amendment rights were not violated. View "Hayat v. Diaz" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Civil Rights, Constitutional Law
Grant v. Belangia
A group of registered voters in South Carolina, all under the age of sixty-five, challenged a provision of state law that restricts “no excuse” absentee-by-mail voting to voters sixty-five years of age or older. These plaintiffs argued that the statute unconstitutionally discriminates against them on account of age, in violation of the Twenty-Sixth Amendment, and also violates the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. The law at issue allows voters sixty-five and older to vote absentee by mail for any reason, while voters under sixty-five can only do so if they meet specific, narrow criteria such as disability, military service, or certain employment conflicts.The case was initially heard in the United States District Court for the District of South Carolina, where the court granted summary judgment in favor of the defendants—the South Carolina State Election Commission and related officials—on both constitutional claims. The district court found that the plaintiffs did not demonstrate a violation of either the Twenty-Sixth Amendment or the Equal Protection Clause. The plaintiffs appealed this decision.The United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit reviewed the appeal. This court held that the plaintiffs have standing and that South Carolina’s age-based absentee-by-mail voting scheme violates the Twenty-Sixth Amendment because it abridges the right to vote on account of age by providing greater ballot access to older voters. However, the court affirmed the district court’s decision to dismiss the Equal Protection claim, as age is not a suspect classification under the Equal Protection Clause and the plaintiffs did not challenge the law under rational basis or Anderson-Burdick scrutiny. The Fourth Circuit reversed the district court’s judgment on the Twenty-Sixth Amendment claim, affirmed the Equal Protection ruling, and remanded the case for appropriate remedy. View "Grant v. Belangia" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Constitutional Law, Election Law
US v. Griffin
Law enforcement officers sought and obtained a no-knock search warrant for a residence in an area known as Kent Bottom, Maryland, based on an affidavit describing the area's reputation for drug activity, criminal histories of individuals associated with the area, and surveillance of suspected drug transactions near the property. The affidavit included descriptions of drug-related incidents from as far back as 2006 involving the residence, as well as more recent but less direct observations of possible drug activity in the general vicinity of the house. The more recent surveillance involved suspected hand-to-hand transactions outside the residence and people entering and leaving the property, but did not directly connect current criminal activity to the interior of the home.After the search, officers recovered drugs and a firearm from a vehicle parked outside the residence. The defendant, who was found inside the house, was charged with several drug and firearm offenses. He moved to suppress the evidence, arguing that the warrant lacked probable cause because the affidavit failed to establish a meaningful connection between the alleged criminal activity and the specific residence. The United States District Court for the District of Maryland denied the motion, reasoning that the history and geography of drug activity in Kent Bottom, along with the observed conduct near the residence, provided a sufficient basis for probable cause.The United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit reversed. It held that the warrant affidavit did not provide a substantial basis for probable cause to search the residence because the facts were either too old, not specifically tied to the home, or both, and therefore failed to establish a fair probability that evidence of a crime would be found inside the house at the time of the search. The court also determined that the good-faith exception did not apply, as the affidavit was so lacking in indicia of probable cause that no reasonable officer could rely on it. The court reversed the district court’s denial of the motion to suppress, vacated the conviction, and remanded for further proceedings. View "US v. Griffin" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Constitutional Law, Criminal Law